James Eterno RIP, we have lost a teacher warrior for NYC schools

 

Today, I  heard the tragic news that James Eterno, NYC teacher, had died, after a major stroke last spring.  He was only 63 years old.  

I got to know James first because of his strong advocacy for smaller classes, and support for the work of Class Size Matters.

 

I got to know him even better through his valiant efforts to save Jamaica HS from closing in 2009-2010

He organized and spoke up at rallies, the PEP, and City Council hearings, the last I recall where he brought students to testify why the school should be saved. 

 

Here is a video of James at rally/meeting to save the school in Dec. 2009.  Check out the comments below the video from former students. Here is another video of him, speaking against Jamaica’s closure, at our Emergency Parent Conference on school closings in Jan. 2010.

As a result of his courageous advocacy, he won the Skinny Award in 2011 as a "teacher-warrior”.   

James not only fought to keep the school open, but even after the PEP rubber stamped the awful decision to phase out the school, he never stopped fighting for the rights of Jamaica students to receive a quality education.

In Sept. 2011, along with the Jamaica HS PTA President, he sent a letter to State Ed Commissioner John King, pointing out how DOE had reneged on its promises  in the Educational Impact Statement to provide adequate resources to the school during the phase-out, so that students in the four academic programs could be provided with the required courses and credits they needed to graduate. He also pointed out how two of the three guidance counselors had been laid off, and the one remaining had a student load of over 600 students.  The DOE had also promised smaller classes as enrollment fell; instead there were 35  classes that violated the UFT class size limits of 34 students per class. I don't know whether John King responded, but given his history of letting DOE get away with anything, likely not.

James continued to teach social studies at Middle College HS.  In 2018, he wrote a brilliant piece for our blog, critiquing the various deeply-flawed educational fads that have been adopted in NYC schools over the years, at that point the Common Core,. On the blog I wrote, if only Chancellor Carranza were listening!  If only he would hire James as his education advisor!  

He also was interviewed on our WBAI radio show and podcast Talk out of School  in Nov.  2021.

James was one of the most vital, energetic, courageous, intelligent, and compassionate people I have ever met.  He will be greatly missed by all who knew him.  My deepest sympathy goes to his family.

Below is an excerpt from my speech at the 2011 Skinny Awards, with praise from a former student and colleagues.

____________

Our last Skinny award goes to someone who I have known and admired for many years.

First of all, I’d like to say that I feel personally connected with the fate of Jamaica as my mother-in-law taught there for many years.   Luckily for her, she passed away a few years ago before she could hear what this administration wants to do with it.  

I met James Eterno about seven years ago and he actually appeared at the first forum I ever organized on class size; I invited a principal, a parent, an academic, a student and a teacher talk about the importance of class size , and James was the teacher, and he spoke eloquently about how much easier it was to engage and reach students when he had the rare chance to have a smaller class.

He has supported our work over the years, even as he has worked hard as a teacher and as an advocate to save his school and steer the entire system in a different direction. 

As a teacher, he is incredibly committed; one of his students. Sharmin Piannca, was quoted in the Queens Chronicle as saying: “The teachers do nothing but good things for you here…Mr. Eterno stayed after school for three hours a day to help me prepare for AP tests.”

I asked Sharmin to share more of her observations.  This is what she wrote:

 “I would love to comment on Mr. Eterno. I've known him for about 3 years now and he's always stepped in as the substitute father figure at school. He is charismatic and builds nothing but good confidence in his students. He'll make you feel like you're on top of the world.

He's very gracious with his time and sacrificed a lot for us. Not to mention he's also a great teacher. I've always had fun debating in both the two classes I had with him-global history and AP U.S history. Frankly, I feel like I'm one step closer to a scholar than the typical high school student, however arrogant that may seem.

Plenty of teachers like Mr. Eterno go unnoticed and I think it's important to shed light on their intelligence and success in the classroom. I can guarantee from the friends I've spoken to over the years from top high schools like Bronx science and Brooklyn Tech don't have teachers that are half as great as some of our teachers at Jamaica like Mr. Eterno."

Incidentally, Sharmin also had wonderful things to say about three other teachers of hers who are here tonight:. …

“Ms. Mclean really pushes her students and is an awesome AP biology teacher,  Mr. Mostachio is a law teacher who is incredibly intelligent not just on the subjects he teaches but life in general, and Ms. Sutera, who is just so strong and powerful-not just because she's a phys ed teacher but she loves what she does and she's a darn good coach!”

But to get back to James.  I have seen him countless times, at rallies, at hearings, and even testifying at City Council hearings about why Jamaica HS must be saved.  He must work 24 hours a day, and is so impressive with the facts,  figures and the passion that make his presentations so compelling.  

I know that he is also an inspiration to his fellow teachers; who were literally banging on the doors to be here tonight, so they could honor him. Here is what a fellow teacher, Marc Epstein had to say:

"I was thinking of a way to best describe James’s role as defender of the teaching staff at embattled Jamaica High School, to those who don’t know him, and this is what came to mind.

If you were in a foxhole on Guadalcanal in 1942, and you faced a nighttime banzai attack from Japanese Imperial marines, you’d want James in the foxhole with you.
 
Conversely, if James was fighting for Emperor Hirohito in the jungles of the Philippines, I can guarantee you that he’d still be carrying out his duties in defense of the empire in 2011.
 
If all our UFT chapter chairs were as tenacious, fearless, and as well versed in the teacher’s contract as James is, I doubt that we’d be in the mess we are in today.”
 
Here  is what another fellow teacher, Dena Gordon, said about James:

“James Eterno is what a chapter leader should be. He fights for all of us. He has fought to improve the educational opportunities for all the children of New York. I feel so lucky to be able to stand by James during this difficult time and have him by my side. He has mentored a generation of people showing what it really means to fight for the children of this city of New York.”

James, will you come and receive the 2011 Skinny award, as a teacher warrior, battling to save NYC schools?

 

After 32 years of teaching, wisdom from James Eterno on Common Core and other education fads

James Eterno

This blog post is by James Eterno, public school teacher and advocate who is retiring after 32 years of teaching.  This included many years as a beloved social studies teacher at Jamaica HS, which James valiantly fought to keep open, and three and half years at Middle College high school, as an esteemed member of the Absent Teacher Reserve.  Here is a video of James at a Jamaica HS rally.  James won our Skinny Award in 2011 as a "teacher-warrior" who gave us the "real skinny" on closing schools.  Much wisdom is expressed in his observations below; if only Chancellor Carranza were listening!  If only he would hire James as his education advisor!

Common Core is Just Another Education Flavor of the Month

In thirty-two years of teaching in the New York City Public Schools, I have seen educational fads come and go. They are usually disguised as new ideas. I started back in the age of A Nation at Risk. The 1983 report that was required reading in education classes in college said we were a country in trouble because of our educational system, so something had to be done. This led to the education profiteers being able to get rich by curing educational malaise. 

Every so often there was a new “flavor of the month” that was going to save our children and make them able to compete on the world educational stage.

The first I remember at Jamaica High School was minimal expectations. Apparently, in those days we were expecting too much from our young people so we now had to convince them they could all meet basic standards. This was the age of the New York State Regents Competency Tests (RCTs) when students had to pass basic competency exams in math, reading, science, global history and American history in order to graduate, if they could not pass the tougher New York State Regents exams. As the RCT’s were implemented, a whole new industry of test review books allowed people to make money selling the new review guides.

Next up in my memory was something called “mastery learning” where the students were allowed to take the tests at the end of each unit over and over until they succeeded. There was no such thing as failure. It slowed us down but mastery was the trend at the time. At this time there was also a big push to make our lesson plans have “power aims.” I really am having a difficult time recalling what a “power aim” was but I do remember we had to have one if we wanted a good review when observed.

However, times changed. I once sat with a supervisor who told me that we had to have a focus question in our lessons instead of a power aim. When I asked the assistant principal after listening politely for about twenty minutes on why a focus question was more relevant than an aim if any of this made a difference to the kids, he quickly came back to reality and said no. He was one of the best supervisors I ever had.

The next great trend was portfolios (making a comeback today) where we kept everything the kids wrote  in huge file cabinets to show how they were growing throughout the year. What a nightmare in a school with space issues.

As we moved into the 21^st Century, Michael Bloomberg was elected mayor of New York City. In 2002, Governor George Pataki and the New York State Legislature gave the mayor control of the city schools. First we had to have bulletin boards plastered with student work in a certain way, a mandated curriculum, literacy and math coaches in all schools, and only offer “mini lessons” because for most of the  class time,  students had to be broken up into small groups to talk to each other.  A CD put out by the Department of Education proclaimed,  “Your students must not be sitting in rows. You must not stand at the head of the class. You must not do ‘chalk and talk’ at the blackboard. You must have a ‘workshop’ in every single reading period. Your students must be ‘active learners,’ and they must work in groups.”   This was called the Workshop Model. 

If we did direct instruction for more than ten minutes, we could be in trouble. Never mind that it may take a much greater time than ten minutes for students to understand the Electoral College or Marbury v. Madison. The kids had to teach themselves for the bulk of the period. I was fortunate at the time that the administration at Jamaica was only partially sold on the Workshop Model.

The Workshop Model was succeeded by accountable talk. I’m sorry but I’m still not sure what this was but I was never cited for not doing it so I must have figured it out. At yet a later point during the Bloomberg administration, he gave principals near total authority over their schools. This was called “autonomy” so the Workshop Model was ditched if the principal didn’t like it. Principals could do as they like as long as the test scores and promotion numbers looked good. 

Another  trend was differentiated instruction. We had to personalize our lessons for each student. A great idea but not practical at all as the Regents exams that students had to pass to graduate were not differentiated, and it is near impossible to really “personalize” lessons when there are more than thirty high school students in a class . Strangely, no one ever mentioned reducing class size, instead of these fads, which would actually make sense.

There were some other fads that didn’t last long enough for me to process.  Whenever someone would come into Jamaica High School to peddle the latest educational cure-all, we  cynical teachers would always suspect  that someone closely connected to the DOE or State Education Department had won a generous contract, and they would try to convince us that this latest fad was the greatest educational innovation since someone figured out how to put chalk on a blackboard. It was always supposed to be the best invention, that is, until the next one came along.

The next boondoggle, the biggest of them all, was the Common Core state standards. Multi-billionaire Bill Gates was behind this one as was President Barack Obama and his Secretary of Education Arne Duncan. They created Race to the Top to make states compete for federal money. We had to use the Common Core if we wanted the federal funds. UFT President Michael Mulgrew threatened to punch anyone in the face who took away his Common Core.

Recently, I read about the shifts in instruction with Common Core in California where some students couldn’t even identify what the change was. In New York, they call the Common Core changes to teaching the instructional shifts. Just like with all of the other fads, the Board of Education, now called the Department of Education, sent someone to Jamaica High School to preach the Common Core gospel.

This very nice consultant from Australia wasn't just there to do a staff development in 2013 at Jamaica High School that was phasing out by then in part because we wouldn’t play with student numbers; she was going to come every week to show us how to shift our instruction to align to the Common Core. What a year!

In social studies we were given a task. We had to come up with a unit in American history on the United States in World War I . This was the Common Core instructions  from Engage NY: "Students build knowledge about the world (domains/content areas) through TEXT rather than the teacher or activities." TEXT is now the key to life. The three teachers who were left in the Social Studies Department at Jamaica scoured through what was left of our book room and searched the internet to find as many sources as we could on the United States' entry into World War I, which turned out to be the focus instead of the entire US experience in World War I. Previously, we were told the Workshop Model or power aims would cure cancer but now it’s TEXT.

Our Australian instructor wanted us to incorporate as much TEXT as we could and go over it in a number of ways so that we could adhere to the state standards on the "Staircase of Complexity". We had to convince students to "read the central, grade appropriate text around which instruction is centered. Teachers are patient, create more time and space and support in the curriculum for close reading." What that meant in reality was that we had to read the same piece from so many different angles until all of us were completely bored to tears.

Meanwhile, we had the United States History and Government Regents exam to worry about too, because those minimum expectations were so 20th Century. By 2013,  the educational establishment also wanted “rigor” and our students, many of whom were English Language Learners, had to pass five Regents exams (no more RCT’s) to graduate from high school. We did not have the luxury of spending a week or more reading about and analyzing the United States entry into World War I from seventeen different viewpoints and then reviewing the same texts over and over until we could get up that "Staircase of Complexity" to educational nirvana.

We abandoned the project, the staff developer eventually moved on and was replaced by a former DOE administrator who told us that teaching the students all of the topics that might come up on the Regents exam was a smart move on our part -- but there was still the Common Core to adhere to.

In the end teachers learned that we had to alter our lesson plans to make sure that we had a standard or two from the New York State Common Core Social Studies Framework on each lesson plan. If we had a standard in the lesson plan, then we were okay  for the Common Core part of the lesson if a school level or district level administrator examined our planning. When I moved on after Jamaica closed to Middle College High School, the administration talked the Common Core talk and told us most of us were teaching to the Common Core but I really couldn't tell anyone how I was adhering to the Common Core except I still had to write a Common Core standard on lesson plans that I was writing anew.

Middle College is a New York Performance Standards Consortium school so we worked with project based learning instead of worrying about students passing all the Regents exams, since the school is exempt from all of them except English. Having the freedom to explore different ways of teaching and not worrying about a state exam in some ways made me a better teacher. Lower class size at Middle College certainly helped too.

The Michael Bloomberg way of trying to quantify everything like Fredrick Winslow Taylor’s early 20th century scientific management to make teaching teacher proof, has proven to be utterly absurd. Yes, fear of closing a school could make teachers pass everyone. If the teachers resisted, Joel Klein just closed the school like he did to Jamaica, and the new teachers in the replacement schools got the message and passed virtually everyone. 

I had people from two other big high schools in Queens tell me their principals told teachers that they better pass the kids or end up like Jamaica. This is not education; it is playing with numbers, though admittedly it did raise our graduation rates. On the other hand, New York City sends so many students to college totally unprepared for the challenge so the college graduation rates are not exactly rising like the high school graduation rates.

Teaching is more an art than a science. What works for me is usually throwing out a topic and then seeing where the discussion goes. If it goes in the right direction, I ask the students to do further research in the area. It doesn't work in every class or with every student. My style will not necessarily be right for other teachers. What works for them may not be a good fit for me. There are as many different teaching styles as there are teachers and students have different learning styles. At Middle College High School and sometimes at Jamaica, we learned from other teachers as we did inter-visitation. When I look back, most of the best advice I received came from just talking to other teachers.

If the past is a guide, Common Core will run its course and be replaced by some new educational fad that some salesman will say is going to make every student ready to be Albert Einstein. Instead, it might help if the powers that be at the State Education Department and the NYC Department of Education would just listen to teachers as well as independent research and reset this whole mess.