Monday, July 23, 2018

Yaffed files suit against Governor Cuomo, Commissioner Elia and Board of Regents for violating US constitution when it comes to ultra-Orthodox schools

Below is one of the most substantive, alarming  press releases I have ever read, announcing a lawsuit launched today vs the Governor, Commissioner Elia and the Board of Regents, from the Yaffed website here.  There is also an AP article about the lawsuit.

I found this statistic  in the press release especially alarming.  Because of the Hassidic community's high birth rate, "it is projected that by 2030, between 8% and 13% of school-age children in New York City, and between 23% and 37% of school-age children in Brooklyn, will be Hasidic, meaning without action, even more students are on track to being denied a sound, basic education."

See also the YouTube video featuring disillusioned alumni of the Hassidic Yeshivas, as well as Diane Ravitch, Ruth Messenger, and me, about the Mayor's unconscionable delay in investigating and regulating these substandard schools.




YAFFED Files Federal Lawsuit Against New York Governor, NYS Education Commissioner, Board of Regents Chancellor Alleging Unconstitutional “Felder Amendment” Denies Yeshiva Students Right to Basic Education

 

Hundreds of Millions of Taxpayer Dollars Support Schools that “Graduate” Students with Few Skills; Poverty Rates and Public Assistance Sky High

(New York, NY) – Today, Young Advocates for Fair Education (YAFFED), a nonprofit committed to improving educational curricula within ultra-Orthodox schools, filed a lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York in Brooklyn against New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, the New York State Education Commissioner MaryEllen Elia, and N.Y. Board of Regents Chancellor Betty Rosa.  YAFFED is represented by lawyers from the law firm of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP as pro-bono counsel.

The suit alleges that on April 12, 2018, when Governor Andrew Cuomo signed into law a budget that included an amendment to New York Education Law, Section 3204, section 2, known as the “Felder Amendment”, New York created a carve-out to the statutory requirement of substantial equivalent instruction in non-public schools that applies to and is intended to benefit only certain ultra-Orthodox non-public schools. In doing so, New York violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

The amendment to Section 3204 is the brainchild of State Senator Simcha Felder and ultra-Orthodox community leaders who oppose state oversight of yeshivas.  Senator Felder attracted much attention in late March when he single-handedly held the 2018 state budget negotiations hostage, demanding the Education Law be changed to inoculate ultra-Orthodox Jewish non-public schools from oversight before agreeing to pass the budget.

"All across America, special interest groups and individuals seek to chip away at a child’s access and right to a comprehensive education. Nowhere have they been more successful than right here in New York, where many yeshivas have gotten away with providing no secular education at all, or at best a very limited one, to tens of thousands of children. This sub-standard secular education was codified into law with Senator Felder’s amendment." said Naftuli Moster, YAFFED‘s Founder and Executive Director.

As of June 2018, there were 273 Orthodox yeshivas registered with the state; 211 of these yeshivas are located in Kings County.  In 2013-14, there were over 52,000 students enrolled in 83 Hasidic schools in New York City, concentrated in the neighborhoods of Borough Park, Williamsburg, Crown Heights (all in Brooklyn). An additional 26,446 students were enrolled in Hasidic schools in places such as Monsey, New Square, and Kiryas Joel. Oversight of these schools by education officials in New York was already non-existent, resulting in many schools flouting state laws.  It is projected that by 2030, between 8% and 13% of school-age children in New York City, and between 23% and 37% of school-age children in Brooklyn, will be Hasidic, meaning without action, even more students are on track to being denied a sound, basic education.

“The Felder Amendment tailors State oversight for a small subset of schools based on their religious affiliation, in a clear violation of the U.S. Constitution.  There is no secular legislative purpose for the Felder Amendment, which is seen by the ultra-Orthodox Jewish religious sects as an endorsement of their religious choice regarding education.” said Eric Huang, lead counsel for YAFFED.

Even though the new amendment creates a carve-out that relieves ultra-Orthodox yeshivas from following the rigorous standards set in state education laws for all other non-public schools, these yeshivas continue to benefit from hundreds of millions of tax-payer dollars annually.  Federal money flows to yeshivas through programs such as Title I, II, and III; Head Start and child care contracts; the E-rate telecommunications program; and food programs. For example, non-public schools in the largely Hasidic neighborhood of East Ramapo received approximately $835 per student in federal Title funding in 2016-17. In addition, state and city funding is provided to yeshivas through Academic Intervention Services (AIS), Nonpublic School Safety Equipment (NPSE), Mandated Services Aid (MSA), the Comprehensive Attendance Program (CAP), EarlyLearn, Universal Pre-K, child care vouchers, and New York City Council discretionary funds.

It is a well-established fact, going back decades, that most Hasidic boys’ yeshivas, some Hasidic girls’ schools as well as non-Hasidic, ultra-Orthodox boys’ schools fail to provide a basic education to their students. Leaders in the ultra-Orthodox community often boast about the fact that many yeshivas focus on only providing students with a religious education, particularly for boys who are all expected to become rabbis.  Few yeshivas administer state tests, including Regents exams, and most yeshivas do not award “graduates” a diploma, making post-secondary education nearly impossible.

The “Education Clause” in Article XI, section 1 of the New York State Constitution ensures the availability of a “sound basic education” to all children in the State and creates the right to adequate instruction along with all the resources that such instruction requires. For public schools, the curriculum for grades one through eight must include instruction in the subject areas of arithmetic, reading, spelling, writing, the English language, geography, United States history, civics, hygiene, physical training, the history of New York State, and science. In high school, academic instruction must include instruction in the English language and its use, civics, hygiene, physical training, American history including the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution of the United States.  Many yeshivas fail to provide any instruction comparable to instruction in these subject areas.
At many ultra-Orthodox yeshivas, the language of instruction is almost exclusively Yiddish. From ages 7 to 12 many Hasidic boys receive instruction in basic English reading, writing, and arithmetic for only 90 minutes a day, four days a week.

Male students over the age of 13 often spend 12 hours a day receiving instruction only in Judaic studies with no secular instruction.

In a recent survey conducted by YAFFED, of 116 yeshiva graduates and parents of current students, not a single respondent said that their school provided instruction in every subject required by the state.  In elementary schools, 65% of those who attended Hasidic yeshivas reported having received some education in English reading, 61% in English writing, and 65% in arithmetic.  Less than a quarter (24%) reported learning U.S. History, and only 2% learned New York history.  Only 8% of Hasidic boys in the survey received instruction in science, and 10% were taught geography.  None recalled any education in art or music.  Of the respondents who attended elementary-level Hasidic yeshivas for boys in New York City, 27% said they received no secular education at all in elementary school. At the high school level, 75% of respondents said they received no secular education at all, and for the 25% who did, it was typically optional and often discouraged. Only 14% of respondents said they learned English; 7% in mathematics; 18% in science; and 9% in social studies.  None had art or music classes.

Not surprisingly, Hasidic families are at high-risk for poverty and reliance upon government assistance.  Approximately 45% of Hasidic households in New York are poor and another 18% are near poor.  In the largely Hasidic area of Williamsburg, the median household income is $21,502, compared to the Brooklyn median of $46,958 and the city median of $52,737. Hasidic communities in Brooklyn have a greater percentage of families receiving cash assistance, food stamps, public health care coverage, and Section 8 housing vouchers, as compared to Brooklyn and New York City as a whole.  For example, 33.8% of Borough Park residents utilize Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) food stamps; in Williamsburg, the number is an astounding 51.8%. The Brooklyn total is 23.8%, while 20.4% of all New York City residents receive SNAP food stamps.

The percentage of people in a heavily Hasidic district of Brooklyn utilizing public income support such as cash assistance (TANF), Supplemental Security Income (SSI), and Medicaid has increased dramatically in the last decade as the population grew rapidly without improvements in education.  In Borough Park, 63.1% of the civilian non-institutionalized population receives public health care coverage, compared to 42.7% of all Brooklyn residents and 39.5% in New York City as a whole. In Williamsburg, the proportion of residents receiving public health coverage is 76.6%.

The ultra-Orthodox Satmar Hasidic town of Kiryas Joel was named the poorest town in the country in 2011, with 70 percent of the village’s 21,000 residents living in households whose income fell below the federal poverty threshold. And in 2018, the largely ultra-Orthodox town of New Square was found to be the poorest town in New York State.

“New York’s tens-of-thousands of yeshiva students deserve better – they deserve, like all students, the right to develop the skills that will enable them to lead independent, financially secure lives. With this lawsuit, we’re making it clear: Hasidic children have the right to the education that is constitutionally guaranteed to them by the state of New York.” concluded Moster.

About YAFFED
YAFFED is an advocacy group committed to improving educational curricula within ultra-Orthodox schools. We fervently believe that every child is entitled to a fair and equitable education that is in compliance with the law. Our work involves raising awareness about the importance of general studies education, and encouraging elected officials, Department of Education officials and the leadership of the ultra-Orthodox world to act responsibly in preparing their youth for economic sufficiency and for broad access to the resources of the modern world.
###

Wednesday, July 18, 2018

Dear Parents and Educators,
NYC Kids PAC enthusiastically endorses the following candidates running for the State Legislature in the Democratic  primary on September 13, 2018:
(If you don’t know which Senate or Assembly district you live in, click on the links above.)
We support these candidates on the basis of their progressive records and their excellent responses on the NYC Kids PAC education survey.  (You can see their responses here [link], along with the surveys of their opponents if they returned them.)
Three of the candidates for Senate, Jessica, Zellnor and Robert, are also challenging sitting legislators who had previously joined the IDC, the Independent Democratic Caucus.  Until recently, the IDC worked with GOP members to block critical education fun
ding and support the further privatization of our public schools.
Four of our five endorsees , although relatively new to electoral politics, bring impressive resumes, energy and commitment to their campaigns.  
One of them is a seasoned veteran,Robert Jackson, who has extensive experience as the chair of the NYC Council Education Committee and a twenty-five year history of education advocacy as a school board president and lead plaintiff in the CFE lawsuit to obtain fair funding for NYC schools.  
NYC Kids PAC decided not to endorse in the primary for governor.  We are no fans of Gov. Cuomo, who has shirked his responsibility to fairly fund NYC schools and has shown undue preferences for privately-run charter schools that often violate student rights and divert even more funding and space from our public schools.  While Cynthia Nixon’s survey responses [LINK] were convincing on the need to increase education funding, keep the cap on charter schools, and reduce the emphasis on standardized tests, on several other important issues, including mayoral control, parent and CEC empowerment, class size and the Common Core standards, her responses were disappointing.
We urge all NYC parents and concerned citizens to vote for the candidates below; even more importantly, to contribute to and/or volunteer for their campaigns.  


Jessica Ramos: Volunteer or Donate.







Julia Salazar: Volunteer or Donate







Zellnor Myrie: Volunteer or Donate





Robert Jackson: Volunteer or Donate.





Catalina Cruz: Volunteer or Donate.








We may be making additional endorsements in the coming weeks; please stay tuned!
Shino, Isaac, Gloria, Fatima, Leonie, Eduardo, Shino, Andy, Brooke, Jiin Wen, Naila, Karen and Tesa www.nyckidspac.org

Tuesday, July 17, 2018

Parent sues City Hall for refusing to release unredacted decision memo on class size

Decision memo p.2
Update: Tomorrow, Wed. May 15 at 2:30 PM at the NY Supreme Court, 60 Centre St., Rm. 418, Judge Arthur Engeron will hear arguments in this lawsuit vs NYC for redacting nearly the entire City Hall decision memo on why the Mayor rejected the Blue Book Working Group recommendations to align school capacity with smaller classes.

For immediate release: July 17, 2018
For more information contact: Leonie Haimson; leoniehaimson@gmail.com; 917-435-9329.

On Monday, July 16, 2018, Brooke Parker, a NYC public school parent, filed a lawsuit against the Office of the Mayor of the City of New York, challenging the almost complete redaction of a City Hall Decision Memo that contained a discussion of the reasons for the city’s rejection of several recommendations of the Blue Book Working Group, including a proposal to align the school capacity formula with smaller class sizes.  She is represented in court by Laura D. Barbieri, Special Counsel of Advocates for Justice, a pro-bono law firm.
Brooke is also a member of NYC Kids PAC, which had sent a candidate survey to Bill de Blasio when he first ran for Mayor.  In June 2013, his campaign returned the survey, in which he promised to  “Reform the blue book formula so it more accurately reflects overcrowding and incorporates the need for smaller classes.”
In February 2014, his newly-appointed Chancellor Carmen Farina appointed a working group to come up with proposals to improve the accuracy of the formula used to devise school capacity and utilization. The working group contained administrators, teachers and parents, and was co-chaired by Lorraine Grillo, the President of the School Construction Authority and Shino Tanikawa,  a parent leader and then-President of the Community Education Council in District 2 in Manhattan.
As explained by a NYC DOE spokesperson, “"Over the last decade, communities across the city have been cut out of decision-making processes that undermined the voices of educators and families. That approach is now gone—and we're replacing it with one that reflects a genuine desire to engage with communities.  With new leadership that will listen, it's a new era for our system. Families and educators need to know that we're going to seek their feedback and engage with them as much as we can."
The Blue Book Working Group made its first round of proposals that were accepted by the DOE in June 2014, including that trailers would no longer be counted in estimating school capacity.  In December 2014, the Working Group proposed thirteen more changes to the formula, including that the DOE should align the school capacity formula to the smaller class sizes in their original, state-approved Contract for Excellence class size reduction plan.  This would require a formula that assume no more than 20 students per classroom in grades K-3, 23 students in grades 4-8 and 25 students in high school, to ensure adequate space to lower class size to those levels. 
On July 28, 2015, without explanation, the City sent an email to reporters, in which the seven recommendations that were accepted were noted, as well as three proposals it would “study.” The email omitted any mention of the three proposals it had rejected outright, including the one that several members of the Working Group said was the most important: to align school capacity with smaller classes.
As Lisa Donlan, a member of the BBWG and the President of the Community Education Council in District 1 said at the time, “Certainly for me and for many of us, the class size issue was the biggest issue that we felt would have the greatest impact on bringing us to painting an accurate picture of reality and making sure that all kids got access to an adequate education — hands down.”
When reporters asked why the City had rejected the proposal on class size, the only answer offered by a Department of Education spokesman was that schools would "continue to work toward this critical goal" of reducing class sizes.
Following up on an earlier Freedom of Information request by Leonie Haimson of Class Size Matters, Brooke Parker filed a FOIL request in on January 24, 2018 seeking “The City Hall 2015 decision memo about which proposals of the Blue Book working group to accept or reject, with the reasons for this decision included.” 

On February 2, 2018, the Mayor’s office sent in response an eight-page document entitled “Decision memo” that was almost completely blacked out, with no mention of the proposals rejected and no information provided on why certain proposals were accepted and others not.  The rationale offered for the redactions was that the items redacted were “inter-agency discussions” and thus exempt from FOIL, pursuant to Public Officers Law § 87(2)(g).  

Yet this law also states that any “final agency policy or determinations” are not exempt from FOIL, as this memo certainly was.  It also makes clear that any inter-agency materials that contain factual data or instructions to staff that affect the public are not exempt, and it is extremely unlikely that no data or facts were cited in the discussion of these decisions. Ms. Parker appealed the redactions to the City, and on March 15, 2018, Henry T. Berger of the Mayor’s Office responded, “Your appeal is denied because I have determined that the redactions were proper.”  Thus, she had no further option but to file an appeal in court.

As Ms. Parker points out, “The decision made by the Mayor’s office to reject the recommendation of the Blue Book working group to align school capacity with smaller classes was terribly unfortunate, and will make it far more difficult to achieve the smaller classes that NYC children need to receive their constitutional right to a sound basic education, according to the State’s highest court in the CFE case.  But then to suppress any of the reasons for this decision and black out the entire discussion explaining the reasons for it makes the original decision even worse.“

Leonie Haimson, Executive Director of Class Size Matters, adds: “When he was running for office, the  Mayor promised parents that he would reduce class size and align the school capacity formula with smaller classes.  He also promised to bring more transparency and community involvement to decision-making, especially when it came to our schools.  He has so far failed at all three.  Hopefully, the Court will agree that his administration can no longer hide their damaging decisions in a flurry of redactions, but will have to spell out the reasoning behind them.  New York City parents and other stakeholders deserve no less.“

The verified complaint is posted here.
###

Sunday, July 15, 2018

How the NYS Exams are Turning our Children into Zeroes

The following is from Fred Smith, testing expert who in earlier years worked for the NYC Board of Education in its Assessment office. You can also check out news articles about the findings of this report here and here.

The latest report issued by SUNY, New Paltz’s Benjamin Center for Public Policy Initiatives, Tests are Turning Our Children into Zeroes: A Focus on Failing, confirms the misgivings of parents about problems with the state exams in 2012 and 2013, as well as the Common Core standards with which they were aligned. Robin Jacobowitz, the Center’s director of education projects, worked closely with me in preparing the report, but I take full responsibility for its contents.

Data for the study came from two sources, the New York State Education Department (SED) and the New York City Department of Education (DOE). Obtaining information from the state required several Freedom of Information law requests, was difficult, time-consuming and only partially successful. The DOE provided our data promptly without a FOIL.

Background and Rationale. We studied the results of state exams for grades 3-8 from 2012 through 2016, starting when SED transitioned to the Common Core Learning Standards.

NCS Pearson, Inc. was awarded a $32 million contract to develop Core-aligned measures for students in grades 3 to 8 in 2011. Pearson’s exams were billed as more “rigorous,” in keeping with the tougher learning standards, the heart of the so-called “education reform agenda” of Commissioner John B. King and Regents Chancellor Merryl Tisch.

Test results were to be used to see where students stood in English and math, and to follow their progress in meeting the standards. In addition, overreaching efforts were made to incorporate the scores into formulas for rating teacher effectiveness, judging principal performance and justifying actions to reorganize or close schools.

The very first day of testing in 2012 saw 192,000 students take Pearson’s English Language Arts (ELA) tests in Grade 8. An eye-opener came two just days later when Leonie Haimson reported on this blog about “The Hare and the Pineapple,” a preposterous reading passage, a story which quickly went viral. The next day, Education Commissioner King, a champion of the more stringent testing, threw out the rotten pineapple along with its six confusing multiple-choice (MC) items. This led to colorful parent-children protests outside Pearson’s New York City offices and gave impetus to the growth of the opt out movement.

The next year, 2013, was SED/Pearson’s foundational year, to establish a Common Core baseline against which to measure growth. Parents in growing numbers throughout the state began to realize that testing was becoming the expanding center of the school universe—too much classroom time spent in preparing students for the exams and conducting them; too much import given to the results of a single test on which to base high-stakes decisions; consequent concern over the pressure children felt during the lengthy testing period. A watchword was born: “My child is more than a test score!”

After the April 2013 ELA was given, further criticisms arose from a larger number of parents, teachers and principals, including that the tests were too long; many items didn’t have clear answers; reading passages were developmentally inappropriate for the students, especially the youngest ones; English Language Learners and students with disabilities were left in a daze; and too many children were experiencing stress before, during and after the exams. The scaling of these exams was also controversial and linked to excessively high SAT scores.

SED dismissed the negative reactions as being anecdotal, coming from the usual naysayers and not backed up by any evidence. Yet at the same time, SED had stopped revealing the kind of data needed to evaluate the quality of the exams and to determine whether the parents’ charges were well-founded. This Catch-22 fueled my indignation.

Up until 2011, SED had posted complete copies of the exams on its website shortly after they had been given. [See this page for 2006-2008 ELA exams, for example, when CTB/ McGraw-Hill was the test publisher.] In addition, statistics for all questions were made available in annual Technical Reports a few months after test administration. Anyone with a certain level of expertise could see how many students chose the “right answer” on multiple choice questions, how many chose each distractor (wrong answer), as well as how many failed to answer at all.

The other part of the ELA consisted of open-ended questions, referred to as constructed response questions (CRQs). These require students to read texts and write answers, which are scored by teachers trained to rate them. In the years prior to the new standards, SED also released these questions and presented a breakdown of the scores for all CRQs, making them openly reviewable in a manner parallel to the multiple-choice items.

SED gave the score distributions for each CRQ, which were worth either two to four points, depending on the question. In all cases, children’s answers could be scored zero, if the writing was judged to be incoherent, irrelevant or unintelligible.

With the advent of Pearson and the emergence of Common Core-based testing, the disclosure of material and data contained in prior Technical Reports was abruptly curtailed, starting in 2011. After 2015, SED stopped posting the annual Technical Reports.

The Common Core-based exams attached increased importance to the CRQs. They represented the highest reflection of the learning standards intended to assess students’ ability to think critically, analyze reading matter, use evidence to support their answers, and respond in an organized and logical way. And, from 2012 through 2016, the CRQ scores assumed greater weight in determining overall performance on the ELA. They accounted for 30% of the points students could earn in 2012, rising to 41% in 2016. Their weight was heaviest—47%—Grades 3 and 4 in 2016.

Because the ELA exams bore the brunt of parental complaints, coupled with my curiosity, CRQs became my area of interest. When we finally received data from the state and the city, we looked at the unanswered CRQs, in addition to the percentage of students who gave answers to questions but received scores of zero.

Findings.

Here are seven takeaway points with regard to student performance on the ELA exams, more specifically how many students received zeros on the CRQs:
  • There was a steep and immediate increase in the percentage of zeroes that New York state students received on the CRQs in 2013, when the Common Core-aligned tests debuted.
  • Particularly sharp increases were evidenced over time in the percentage of zeroes for students in Grades 3 and 4 statewide; this was also true for English Language Learners and students with disabilities in New York City. (The data DOE provided allowed us to analyze the ELA’s impact on subgroups of students.)
  • For 3rd graders, the percentage of zero scores rose from 11% in 2012 to a plateau of 21% in the state and city from 2013 to 2016.
  • In addition to zero scores, there were increasing percentages of unanswered questions statewide (a different category than zeroes) in 2013 over 2012, particularly for Grade 3.
  • SED removed time limits from the state exams in 2016. This reduced the number of unanswered CRQs but the number of zeros stayed the same.
  • There were high percentages of students in grades 3 citywide who got zeroes on half or more of the CRQs, ranging from 5% in 2012 to 13% in 2016. The percentages who got five or more zeroes were much higher for ELLs (33%) and students with disabilities (35%).
  • DOE data revealed that higher percentages of Black and Hispanic students wrote answers deemed incoherent, irrelevant or incomprehensible than did their Asian-Caucasian counterparts. The gap in zero scores between minority group and white students widened between 2012 and 2015, especially in Grades 3 and 4.
Though our findings for subgroups are based on New York City data, a reasonable assumption can be made that they hold for groups statewide since the city forms a major share (37%) of the state’s test population and its constituent groups. Parents throughout the state must let education officials in Albany, their legislators and the Governor know they are dissatisfied with an unaccountable, damaging testing system that has devolved over time. We cannot let another year go by without significant changes in the testing program.


Thoughts, Warnings and Suggested Follow-Up.

Lack of Transparency - Clearly, SED’s suppression of data and lack of transparency is a policy that must be reversed. Lack of timely information allows poor practices to continue unchallenged by objective data. While SED may be the custodian of the information, it is owned and paid for by New York taxpayers. We must demand that NYSED post complete Technical Reports, along with full information about item responses and scoring distributions, promptly after tests are given, as occurred in the past. Questar, the current test vendor, replaced Pearson in 2017, and must provide the kind of item-level data that were previously made public and eventually obtained concerning Pearson’s exams during its five-year run.

Many complaints about current Questar’s exams are similar to those concerning Pearson’s tests. See the observations of teachers who participated in NYSUT’s “Share Your Story” campaign, as compiled in their report, The Tyranny of Testing.

Yet new problems have emerged with the untimed exams. Some children took up to six hours or more to complete the exams, missing lunch in the process. In the many of the 263 New York schools conducting Questar’s computer-based exams, there were glitches and disruptions. It was later revealed that there were Questar breaches of student personal data, in New York and Mississippi. In other words, children were subjected to beta testing for SED and its vendor.

Tennessee has announced it will seek a new test vendor because of all the problems with the administration of the Questar computerized exams. What mechanism exists in New York State to recover money from Questar for poor performance or to terminate the contract? Is SED’s working relationship with test publishers so close that they are, in effect, partners and SED cannot reject Questar without implicating itself in any misdeeds? Can the offices of the State Comptroller and AG intervene?

Warning# 1 – Stand-Alone Field Tests. SED continues to target a large number of schools to try out test material for future operational tests. Separate, no-count field tests are administered at the end of the year on school time. Data gained in this process comes from unmotivated students and yields items that don’t predict how students will respond when publishers select items to go on the “real” exams. This has led to poor operational tests being built by the likes of Pearson and Questar.


Warning#2 – Don’t Attach New Purposes To Bad Tests. Amidst the controversy over the Specialized High School Admissions Test (SHSAT), the Mayor has proposed using students’ state test scores as part of the selection process. This would put higher stakes on these unreliable exams and add an excuse to keep the state testing program alive in its present form.

In addition, the 4th grade ELA is used to screen children for middle schools. Our report finds this test has posed sharp problems for many fourth graders. In effect, the 4th grade test has become a gatekeeper for the “better” New York City middle schools—which are known for getting their kids into the selective high schools. Would any of this solve the underlying problem of quality education for all children?

As long as an ill-conceived testing program exists, reasons will be found to justify its continuance. Though federal law requires standardized tests for grades 3-8 and once in high school, we should ask ourselves what constitutes a legitimate assessment process. Eliminating standardized tests would save vast amounts of money, lower the fever caused by tests, focus on the whole child, and value teachers, other subject matter and different forms of expression..

Having spent 50 years in the testing trenches, and as I look at two dust-covered books, Jonathan Kozol’s Savage Inequalities (1991) and Andrew Hacker’s Two Nations (1992), I would hate to see us wake up in three years, up to our eyeballs in computerized testing, with an ever-increasing achievement gap, still enslaved by the simple-minded dogma that we must have quantitative data, however unreliable and invalid, to make decisions. We have to be smart enough to change an injurious mindset—one that has struck me over time as more intentional than misguided.

~Fred Smith 7-15-18

Sunday, July 1, 2018

My love letter to Diane Ravitch on her 80th birthday

Today is Diane Ravitch's 80th birthday.  Her sons gave her a small party on Thursday night which I was lucky to attend and which filled me with memories.

I recall how I met her in 2006 or 2007.  I found out from a friend that she had attended a fundraiser in Brooklyn for the United Parents Association, a now vanished organization on whose board I served.  I asked another board member what Diane was like, and she told me she was very nice. 

Up to that point I had admired her from afar, as many did, for her brilliant intellect and her courage in opposing Joel Klein's destructive education policies, but feared she might be scary and aloof.

My husband encouraged me to email her, which I did.  I asked if we could have have lunch at a location of her choosing.  We met in Brooklyn and immediately hit it off.  She was super-smart of course, but also very warm, funny, unpretentious and direct.  The connection was immediate; we had so much to talk about there wasn't a second of silence, and we began a vibrant conversation which has continued to this day.

There was much we agreed upon, but also some things we disagreed about.  She was much more of a supporter of standardized testing than I was in those days, and thought the NAEPs should become a  national exam used for accountability purposes.  I argued that this would make the results far less useful and reliable, as there would be test prep and gaming of the test, a la Campbell's Law.  She replied the NAEPs couldn't be gamed. But she didn't flinch or become defensive when I argued with her.  She was so much fun to talk to that I was eager for the next opportunity.

(Our disagreement in retrospect is ironic, because now she's far more opposed to all standardized testing than I am, as I still believe that well-designed exams with no stakes attached can be useful for research and evaluation purposes.)

Then in 2008, I meekly asked her if she would consider serving on the board of Class Size Matters; and was thrilled when she agreed. This was reciprocated in 2013, when she asked me to serve on the board of the Network for Public Education, the advocacy organization which she had just started and I gladly accepted.

I remember how in 2009, after Michael Bloomberg renewed mayoral control, upended term limits and was re-elected for the third time, I was very depressed.  I told her I didn't know whether I could go on fighting him, Joel Klein and their ruthless privatization policies for another four years.  She told me of course I had to continue, there was no giving up and she would help and support me all she could.  Of course she was right.

There is no one in the world whom I respect more, and I remain in awe of her prolific, prodigious productivity.  She blogs ten times a day, writing about the latest political and educational news quicker than I can read, at the same time as she is working on another book, this one about the grassroots resistance to corporate reform.  I send her bits of news daily that I think she might be interested in, as well as animal videos, as she adores animals as much as she loves public education.

As I grow older, and become apprehensive about the aging process, she provides me with the most inspiring example of someone whom age has not slowed down one whit.  I am so lucky to have her in my life, and I know many others feel the same way.

Happy Birthday, Diane.  You mean so much to so many of us.  Thank you for everything; your mind, your heart and your soul.