Actually I was wrong, my tweet was not restored though I had mistakenly seen this in the cached version on my laptop. And Celia removed the questions after being threatened by PARCC.A few days ago, Celia Oyler posted the comments of a teacher who had seen the 4th grade PARCC
exam and included some excerpts and a critique. She pointed out that the reading passages were several grades above 4th. One passage, according to Scholastic, was at an interest level for Grades 9-12, and at a 7th Grade reading level.
Moreover, the questions asked were ridiculously difficult, including one that demanded students "Write an essay that explains the differences in the structural elements between the passage and the poem." Since then, many people have reprinted the post, including at the Daily Kos and elsewhere.
While I was reading the blog post, tremendously appalled, the PARCC folks tweeted this:
I responded this way : @PARCCPlace @JohnKingatED higher standards like asking 4th graders to do "structural analysis" of difficult texts? https://t.co/jQG29pNR5DHigher standards help ensure "all students graduate ready for what’s next." -@JohnKingatED https://t.co/fKEh7R6we5 pic.twitter.com/wR8yjUMXLs— PARCC (@PARCCPlace) May 10, 2016
This afternoon, I got the following message from Twitter, explaining that they had deleted my tweet because of a claim from the PARCC people that it somehow infringed on the "copyright" of Laura Slover, the CEO of PARCC. The complaint was made by Kevin Michael Days, who calls himself "Assoicate Director [sic], Operations" of PARCC.
Can a tweeted link to a blog infringe on a copyright? I find this particularly offensive, especially as it should be legally required to release every high-stakes exam to the public after it is given. How else are we to find out if its appropriate, flawed, or unfair ?
To add insult to injury, the essays of these poor 4th graders are likely to be scored by computers that cannot distinguish sense from nonsense! What do others think?
@leoniehaimsonHello,
The following material has been removed from your account in response to the DMCA takedown notice copied at
the bottom of this email:
- Tweet: https://twitter.com/
leoniehaimson/status/ 730046634453815301 - .@PARCCPlace @JohnKingatED higher standards like asking 4th graders to do "structural analysis" of difficult texts? https://t.co/jQG29pNR5D
If you believe the material has been removed as a result of mistake or misidentification,
you may send us a counter-notification of your objection pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 512(g)(3).
Please include the following in your counter-notification:
- Your full name, address, telephone number, e-mail address, and Twitter user name.
- Identification of the material that has been removed or to which access has been disabled and the location
at which the material appeared before it was removed or access to it was disabled.
- The following statement: “I swear under penalty of perjury that I have a good faith belief that the material was
removed or disabled as a result of mistake or misidentification of the material to be removed or disabled.”
- A statement that you consent to the jurisdiction of the Federal District Court for the judicial district in which
your address is located, or if your address is outside of the United States, the Northern District of California,
and that you will accept service of process from the person who provided notice under 17 U.S.C. 512 (c)(1)(C) or an
agent of such person.
- Your physical or electronic signature
Please send your counter-notification to us as a response to this message, or as a new email to copyright@twitter.com.
We will forward a copy of your counter-notification, including the information required in item 1 above, to the
complainant and Chilling Effects. BY SENDING US A COUNTER-NOTIFICATION, YOU CONSENT TO THIS DISCLOSURE OF YOUR
PERSONAL INFORMATION.
Please note that repeat violations of this policy may result in suspension of your account. In order to avoid this,
do not post additional material in violation of our Copyright Policy and immediately remove any material from your
account for which you are not authorized to post.
******************************
DMCA Takedown Notice
== Copyright owner: Laura Slover
== Name: Kevin Michael Days
== Company: PARCC Inc.
== Job title: Assoicate Director, Operations
== Email address: kdays@parcconline.org
== Address: 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, 6th Floor
== City: Washington
== State/Province: District of Columbia
== Postal code: 20006
== Country: United States
== Phone (optional): 2027488077
== Fax (optional): n/a
-------
== Description of original work: The user has posted a link to blog that contains secured operational items from the computer-based PARCC Grade 4 English Language Arts/Literacy Assessment, including information about the reading passages and essay prompt.
== Links to original work: n/a
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/TestTroublemake/status/ 730240761577521152
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/ergosullivan/status/ 730207985071493122
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/ergosullivan/status/ 730207985071493122
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/twins121407/status/ 730197245132455938
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/apmurphy98/status/ 730122611519262720
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/NYSAPE/status/730087806052278273
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/LIOptOut/status/730087805876113408
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/sheilaresseger/status/ 730071792694534144
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/johnckain/status/730060456371445760
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/whalenmsms/status/ 730060341909069826
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/KatieOsgood_/status/ 730053406895812609
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/leoniehaimson/status/ 730046634453815301
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/justinalpertesq/status/ 730039967246864384
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/PaulaLCSW/status/729078980456919041
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/flolindy1/status/729070041342169088
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/progressive_edu/status/ 729063625910976512
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/collateralmomag/status/ 730695647439904768
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
---
== Reported Tweet URL: https://twitter.com/TechEducator1/status/ 730612315368894464
== Description of infringement: The Infringing Material consists of questions and supporting material relating to the PARCC standardized assessments and no person has been authorized to post or disclose such material other than certain persons authorized to administer the PARCC Assessments in a secure environment. No public disclosure has been authorized for the subject material. In particular, Parcc Inc. has a good faith belief that the use of the material described above has not been authorized by Parcc, Inc. as the owner of the subject copyrights.
-------
== 512(f) Acknowledgment: I understand that under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f), I may be liable for any damages, including costs and attorneys' fees, if I knowingly materially misrepresent that reported material or activity is infringing.
== Good Faith Belief: I have good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.
== Authority to Act: The information in this notification is accurate, and I state under penalty of perjury that I am authorized to act on behalf of the copyright owner.
== Signature: Kevin Michael DaysReference #ref:00DA0000000K0A8.500G000000xZz1c:ref Twitter, Inc. 1355 Market Street, Suite 900 San Francisco, CA 94103
2 comments:
I just asked my father, an attorney said taking the entire contents of an article and re-publishing/posting, most likely is a no no. However, if you are taking an excerpt(s) or the article citing where it came from review and critique, then that is considered 'fair game and use'. It is still good to consult with more privacy/copyright lawyers on this though.
My father also mentioned that Twitter may not want to get into this controversial matter either, in that it is their business to make money and to not have these matters come up on Twitter. So that is another possibility of why it could have also been deleted.
I am emailing you some names of people to contact who I follow on Twitter.
http://petitions.moveon.org/sign/stop-inappropriate-testing?source=c.em&r_by=15701224
Post a Comment