The highlighting above reveals that six of the eleven early voting sites in the Bronx, twelve of eighteen sites in Brooklyn, eight of nine sites in Manhattan and seven of nine sites in Staten Island are public schools. [Why there are an equal number of voting sites in Manhattan and Staten Island is another question, given that there are more than three times as many residents of Manhattan as on Staten Island. Shouldn't the number of sites or at least the number of the voting machines be proportional to the population of each borough?]
In the 33 public schools where early voting will occur, this will deprive many thousands of students of their ability to have their scheduled phys ed classes in their gyms and/or eat lunch in their cafeterias. It will also poses real security risks to students, with hundreds of voters gaining access to school buildings and possibly roaming school hallways during the school day.
One principal was quoted in the Gothamist article as saying, “I can’t not have kids [in the gym] for a week in October. That’s crazy."
At the same time, there is not a single public school that will be used as an early voting site in the borough of Queens, as the city instead wisely located them instead in Board of Election headquarters, YMCAs, community centers, churches, colleges, museums, and even the Resort World Casino in Ozone Park.
I also checked the early voting sites of the 62 other New York counties on the League of Women Voters website. I could find only one other New York county that had any public schools listed: Suffolk County has one public school, Nesconset Elementary School, among ten early voting sites.
The other hundreds of early voting sites located throughout the state include town halls and other government offices, public libraries, fire departments, YMCAs, local Board of election headquarters, community centers, senior centers, County courthouses, churches, recreational centers, office complexes and even malls.
Why NYC had to put so many of their early voting sites in public schools is hard to fathom, when so many other, more appropriate options were available.
Assemblymember Michael Reilly of Staten Island sent a letter to Mayor Bill de Blasio and the Board of Elections last May, expressing his concern over the use of public school facilities for early voting after the preliminary list of sites was announced on April 30.
At that time, only nine of the 38 early voting sites selected were public schools, including five in Brooklyn, three in Manhattan, and only one in Staten Island -- although three parochial schools in the borough were identified at that time, later to be eliminated.
In his letter, AM Reilly, who before his election to the Legislature was a member of Community Education Council 31, pointed out how early voting would be seriously disruptive to these schools:
“At most schools, voting machines are being placed in cafeterias, gymnasiums, and even the building’s main lobby. It impedes a student’s ability to navigate their school safely, and sometimes causes them to miss valuable academic time,” said Reilly. He continued, “Before early voting, schools were disrupted for just a maximum of three or four days each election year, but now we are inconveniencing students, teachers, and administrators for a minimum of 24 days to accommodate a 12-day primary election, and a 12-day general election, not to mention an additional 12-days for any special election. It’s ridiculous, plain and simple.”
According to AM Reilly's twitter feed, his letter got no response, and instead of addressing this situation with the seriousness it deserved, the city added twenty-four more public schools to the list this fall. On October 8, AM Reilly wrote the Mayor again, reaffirming his concerns.
Let's hope this unacceptable situation gets fixed before the the primaries and general election next year.