Questionable contract?

If you want to volunteer for our Citizens Contract Oversight Committee, or have a tip to share, please email us at

Friday, June 20, 2008

What's wrong with the Hebrew charter school by Diane Ravitch

Here we go again….a Hebrew charter school meant for District 22 in Brooklyn. Its founder is yet another child of yet another billionaire – in this case, Michael Steinhardt. In answer to a parent’s question about the school, Diane Ravitch writes:

In brief, my view is that the city should not be creating special schools based on religion, ethnicity, and language. The long-established tradition of public education is that public schools are open to all and offer a curriculum that is appropriate for all.

Because we are such a diverse nation, the public schools provide the common ground for children and families of all backgrounds. This is why in the past most Americans would have immediately and instinctively opposed the creation of a special school for children whose families come from one nation; or one race; or one religion; or one culture. Such a concept is directly in conflict with the mission of American public education, which is to educate our children for citizenship and full participation in our democracy.

Parents who want their children to learn about their heritage culture and language should do so after school. And public schools, for their part, should offer a variety of languages and teach about the nations and cultures of the world.

But it is inappropriate for a public school to teach as if it were a private, sectarian school. That is not what public education is supposed to be.

Authorizing schools that teach only one culture and one language is at odds with the long-established meaning and purpose of public education.

-- Diane Ravitch

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

If we can have an Arabic school, we can have a Hebrew school. It is as simple as that. Those of you who are so against this should have made your intentions known during the Arabic school controversy with Debbie Almontaser.
Those who are against this school are probably the same group who was against the building of a Yeshiva in their neighborhood some time ago.
This Hebrew school wouldn't only be for Jewish children. It would be for all children. In an era of holocaust denial, we may need such a school.
I really have to laugh when people such as Ms.Ravitch, who never taught for one day, is now a self-proclaimed expert in education. Ms. Ravitch and Mr. Klein should be teaching in one of our many SURR schools to get first hand knowledge on what is really going on in our public schools.
I am a retired New York City teacher. I would have loved to have taught in this proposed school or to have attended one as a child. In the 1950s, when I attended the excellent P.S. 241 in Brooklyn, the 23rd Psalm was read in assemblies. Jewish students were forced to participate in Christian plays put on in the auditorium. I guess that was all right with Ms. Ravitch and others.